It Couldn’t Be Dylan
“Have you seen the paper, Dad?” he asked Jay Holliday. “Jess is on the front page.”
Holliday went downstairs and picked up his Denver Rocky Mountain News. On the cover was the same photo Derek had seen in North Dakota: 18-year-old Jessica Holliday, her hands clutching her head, her mouth open in a silent wail. HEARTBREAK read the headline, a word that barely expressed the emotion written on Jessica’s face.
Her anguished image showed up on front pages in every corner of the world – along with magazine covers, the Internet, television. The camera caught a pretty face so distorted by despair that only family and friends knew for certain who it was. And only Jessica herself knew what she had been thinking and feeling just then.
But that didn’t stop the rest of the world from claiming Jessica’s pain as its own.
“That picture tells the whole story,” said Jessica’s mother, Kathy Holliday. “I can’t look at it without crying.”
Jessica’s photo seemed to move everyone except Jessica herself. For her, the events of April 20 seemed unreal, and they still do.
It felt unreal when the killers walked through Columbine ‘s library, laughing and shooting, while she hid under a table and prayed.
Because Jessica Holliday is not just the girl in the picture; she’s the girl in the middle.
She knew the killers, and she knew their victims. They were nice guys. And they murdered her best friend
Jessica had seen Dylan Klebold with the gun before she ducked under the table, and it was difficult for her to reconcile that image with the quiet kid she knew.
“It couldn’t be Dylan,” she thought, even though she knew it was.
Dylan had been in her government class the semester before. He sat right in front of her, so they talked, mostly about homework. He would pass papers back. It couldn’t have been Dylan.
Later, she told her parents how she thought about standing up and telling Eric and Dylan to stop, as if reason might have been bullet-proof. Maybe they wouldn’t have killed her, because they both knew her.
Jessica told her mother she felt like a coward because she didn’t do anything to save her friends. But now she has accepted the fact that there was nothing she could have done.
“Nobody could have stopped them. Nobody,” Jessica said with certainty. “They didn’t have a reason for shooting somebody. They just shot. I think no matter what anybody would have done, if someone had stood up and tried to stop them, that person would have gotten shot.”
When the killers reached Jessica’s table, they had to reload. She heard them talking about cutting someone with a knife, what that would be like.Jessica, dressed in shorts, became painfully aware of her bare legs jutting out from under the table. Would they cut her? she wondered.
Instead, they left to get more ammunition.
She told her story with feeling, but no tears. Her voice resonated with love for Lauren but no hint of bitterness toward Eric and Dylan.
“I don’t have any hate,” Jessica said. “I feel sorry for the boys, because they hated life so much that they had to destroy others. I feel sorry for them. Because they couldn’t enjoy life, like me and Lauren could.”
“I can’t hate them. Because I knew them, both of them.
"But I don’t want to ever think about them again. Because they killed my best friend. My best friend, who knew every little part of my life. They took her.”
Jessica doesn’t like the photo of herself. As many times as she has seen it, she still doesn’t feel its power, even though she knows it has touched millions. It just rubs her the wrong way.
“It was weird to see myself. I didn’t like it, and I still don’t like it,” she said. “I was so sad that day, and so confused. And then here it is, right there. All the stuff I was going through, and everybody could see it.”
(full article here)
The Girl in the Picture
By Lisa Levitt – Rocky Mountain News StaffWriter
On April 20, Jessica Holliday became he face of the Columbine tragedy to millions around the world. This is herstory.
She is a very private person whosevery public moment of grief made her the poster child for unspeakabletragedy.
The flood of unwelcome fame beganthe morning after the deaths at Columbine High School. First came the early
morning call from her brother, Derek, in Bismarck, N.D.
“Have you seen the paper,
Dad?” he asked Jay Holliday. “Jess is on the front page."
Holliday went downstairs and picked
up his Denver Rocky Mountain News. On the cover was the same photo Derek had
seen in North Dakota: 18-year-old Jessica Holliday, her hands clutching her
head, her mouth open in a silent wail. HEARTBREAK read the headline, a word
that barely expressed the emotion written on Jessica’s face.
Her anguished image showed up on
front pages in every corner of the world – along with magazine covers, the
Internet, television. The camera caught a pretty face so distorted by despair
that only family and friends knew for certain who it was. And only Jessica
herself knew what she had been thinking and feeling just then.
But that didn’t stop the rest of the
world from claiming Jessica’s pain as its own.
"That picture tells the whole
story,” said Jessica’s mother, Kathy Holliday. “I can’t look at it
without crying."
Jessica’s photo seemed to move
everyone except Jessica herself. For her, the events of April 20 seemed unreal,
and they still do.
It felt unreal when the killers
walked through Columbine ‘s library, laughing and shooting, while she hid under
a table and prayed. It felt unreal when she went back into the library weeks
later, and saw her best friend’s blood on the floor.
"Even to this day, I like to
pretend that I was out to lunch or at home,” she said. “Or that it
happened at some other school. But not our school."
Because Jessica Holliday is not just
the girl in the picture; she’s the girl in the middle. She knew the killers,
and she knew their victims.
They were nice guys. And they murdered
her best friend.
They sat at the same table, the one
nearest the entrance, every day at lunch time: Val Schnurr, Lisa Kreutz, Jeanna
Parks, Jessica Holliday, Lauren Townsend. All good friends and seniors, excited
about graduation and college.
On that Tuesday, Jessica was sitting
where she always sat, across from her best friend, Lauren. So far, it had been
a great day. Jessica was wearing a new outfit. She was looking forward to
starting a new job. She and Lauren had spent the whole hour before together;
Jessica was counting on Lauren’s help with her physics.
Another friend, Amber Huntington,
caught Jessica’s attention, so she left her usual seat to walk to the back of
the room to talk. And that’s where she was when she heard the first
shots.
Firecrackers, Jessica thought, or
hammers. A senior prank. She didn’t really believe the teacher who came in
yelling about guys with guns.
And then everyone began ducking
under tables, and Jessica started to run back to her table, back to
Lauren.
And at that moment, Amber grabbed
Jessica’s hand and pulled her under the nearest table. “She probably saved my
life,” Jessica said.
Amber hadn’t wanted to go to school
that day. And all morning, she had felt a powerful need to see Jessica, talk to
Jessica. When the shooting began, Amber immediately reached for her
friend.
"I was scared,” Amber
said, “and I wanted Jessica to stay with me."
Back at Jessica’s table, her other
friends had become targets: Val. Jeanna. Lisa.
Lauren.
Under their table, Jessica and Amber
held hands and prayed, through the gunfire, through the screams. Through the
killers’ laughter.
"In that moment, all you can do
is pray that they won’t shoot you, pray that you won’t die,” Jessica said.
“You’re not ready to die.”
Jessica had seen Dylan Klebold with
the gun before she ducked under the table, and it was difficult for her to
reconcile that image with the quiet kid she knew.
“It couldn’t be Dylan,”
she thought, even though she knew it was.
Dylan had been in her government
class the semester before. He sat right in front of her, so they talked, mostly
about homework. He would pass papers back. It couldn’t have been Dylan.
Later, she found out that the other
boy was Eric Harris. That was just as hard to believe.
Eric’s older brother, Kevin, was her
brother Derek’s best friend. Kevin was a great guy, like another brother to
her. Eric had eaten dinner at her house once.
Later, when it was over, Kevin
Harris came to see her.
“Are you OK?” he asked.
And then, “Was it really my brother?"
And Jessica said yes, but she
wouldn’t say more. She felt sorry for Kevin, for all he suffered. But that
couldn’t change what Eric had done.
Later, she told her parents how she
thought about standing up and telling Eric and Dylan to stop, as if reason
might have been bullet-proof. Maybe they wouldn’t have killed her, because they
both knew her.
Later, Jessica told her mother she
felt like a coward because she didn’t do anything to save her friends. But now
she has accepted the fact that there was nothing she could have done.
"Nobody could have stopped
them. Nobody,” Jessica said with certainty. “They didn’t have a
reason for shooting somebody. They just shot. I think no matter what anybody
would have done, if someone had stood up and tried to stop them, that person
would have gotten shot."
When the killers reached Jessica’s
table, they had to reload. She heard them talking about cutting someone with a
knife, what that would be like.
Jessica, dressed in shorts, became
painfully aware of her bare legs jutting out from under the table. Would they
cut her? she wondered.
Instead, they left to get more
ammunition.
The survivors of the library spilled
out from under their tables and began to run.
"And I didn’t want to run.
Because I thought they were going to come back and just shoot us all. So for a
second, I froze,” Jessica said. “Then the people at my table left and
ran, and I finally got up."
And while Jessica ran, she thought
about being shot in the back.
When she got outside, she saw Val,
who was alone and wounded, so Jessica held her. And then Jeanna was there, and
she had been shot, too. Surrounded by her friends, bleeding.
But no Lauren.
"Where’s Lauren?” she
asked Diwata Perez, who had been sitting at their table up front.
“We tried to wake her up,”
Diwata said. “Her eyes were closed. Maybe she passed out."
And at that moment, Jessica knew
what had happened to Lauren.
"Lauren is the strong one,
she’s the survivor. She’s the one who would bail me out of anything,” Jessica
said.
“So I knew she was
dead."
The bullet that killed Lauren broke
Jessica’s heart.
They became friends in their
first-grade class, once-in-a-lifetime kind of friends. They went on a church
retreat every winter during high school, where they’d talk about God and their
feelings and their lives.
"We’d talk about our way-down
secrets that we wouldn’t tell anybody else,” Jessica said. “Lauren
had problems, but she’d never really let anybody know. She talked to me about
it. But she never had a bad day. She had quiet days. But not bad
days."
Lauren was always there: Coming over
late to help Jessica with her math homework. Picking out Jessica’s prom dress
with five days to go. Always ready to listen.
They were bound together by their
love of music – both played the piano and the clarinet – and by more difficult
things, like the health problems suffered by Jessica’s mother, Kathy, and
Lauren’s mother, Dawn.
"We talked really in-depth on
the winter retreat,” Jessica said. “Sometimes about God, but mostly
about what we were going through in life right now, what it’s like. Me and
Lauren, sometimes we don’t have easy lives. And we talked about
that."
They drew strength from each other –
and Lauren drew pictures for Jessica. Jessica saved them all. Sleeping Beauty.
Jasmine. Jessica as Pocahontas. “We always sang Jesus Christ Superstar, and
we’d dance to it. And so she drew Jesus on the cross for me.”
On the back, Lauren wrote, “May He
always be with you.”
A week before she died, Lauren gave
Jessica her last drawing.
"She had smudged it,”
Jessica said. “And I remember her saying, ‘I had a picture for you, but I
ruined it. So I’ll redraw it for you.’ She never did. And finally I said,
‘Lauren, can I have that picture you smudged?’
So Lauren gave it to her. Her last
drawing: an unfinished angel.
It was a day after the shootings
before Jessica knew for sure what her heart already had told her: that Lauren
was dead. She felt anger then, and a survivor’s guilt.
“If anything, I should have
been the one to die, and not Lauren,” Jessica said. “For the first
couple of days after, I thought, if I would have stayed at our table, I would
have gotten shot and not Lauren – Lauren would have been safe. Or if I was
there, my angel that was with me would have been with my whole table, and my
whole table would have been OK."
Lauren’s parents asked to see her,
and she didn’t know what she would say to them.
"Her mother wanted to know
exactly what had happened,” Jessica said. “And I told her most of it.
But not all of it."
She told them about things she and
Lauren had done together that they never knew about. She told them about
Lauren’s drawings, which she gave them for an art show. She took Lauren’s
yearbook and had all her best friends sign it, and then brought it back to
Lauren’s parents.
At Lauren’s funeral, and the Red
Rocks memorial, Jessica stood in front of friends and family and strangers and
brought to life the Lauren she knew, the smart, funny, down-to-earth girl who
had a thing for space aliens and was perpetually late. A person everybody
loved. A person without an enemy in the world.
"Your best friend doesn’t
die,” Jessica said. “Even to this day, I don’t believe it. I think
maybe I could go call her, and she’ll be home.
"And I’ll say, ‘What’s
up?’"
Jessica doesn’t like the photo of
herself. As many times as she has seen it, she still doesn’t feel its power,
even though she knows it has touched millions. It just rubs her the wrong
way.
"It was weird to see myself. I
didn’t like it, and I still don’t like it,” she said. “I was so sad
that day, and so confused. And then here it is, right there. All the stuff I
was going through, and everybody could see it.”
What people see now is a young woman
looking forward. In the fall, Jessica plans to go to Mesa State College. She
isn’t sure what she’ll study. But April 20 gave her a new perspective on her
future.
“I want to live more like
Lauren – try to get along with everybody, try to work harder. She’s my
hero,” Jessica said. “I want to do something to help people. So that
every day is like a new day, you know?"
Jessica still struggles to get past
that one day. She returned to the library with the other survivors, thinking
that it would help her accept Lauren’s death. But it didn’t help at all.
She saw the bullet holes and the
blood. It was like a movie set, like dye splashed on the floor. All of it,
still so unreal, obscured by a heavy curtain of denial that Jessica has yet to
pull back.
She told her story with feeling, but
no tears. Her voice resonated with love for Lauren but no hint of bitterness
toward Eric and Dylan.
"I don’t have any hate,”
Jessica said. “I feel sorry for the boys, because they hated life so much
that they had to destroy others. I feel sorry for them. Because they couldn’t
enjoy life, like me and Lauren could."
"I can’t hate them. Because I
knew them, both of them.
"But I don’t want to ever think
about them again. Because they killed my best friend. My best friend, who knew
every little part of my life. They took her."
Jessica’s parents worry about her.
“She’s strong, so strong,” said Jessica’s mother, Kathy. “But she hasn’t dealt
with all of this yet. She hasn’t cried. I cry all the time. But she hasn’t
cried.”
She wasn’t crying in that photo,
either, Jessica insisted. People seemed to think they could look at her face
and know her thoughts in that terrible second. Life magazine printed the
picture with a caption that said Jessica was reacting to the news that her best
friend was dead.
That wasn’t it.
"I was praying,” she said.
“And I was asking, ‘What just happened? Why our school? Why is everybody
hurting?’ I was thinking about Lauren, and I was asking why? Why?
“It was a moment with
God."
Related Links:
Jessica Hollidays 11K account
Dylan straddling Jessica’s leg