
Human Existence – March 31, 1997
In his first entry Dylan dwells on the past and describes how different he feels from the lives that jocks have. But he also brings up deeply philosophical themes of existence, the mind and human nature.
Everything Connects
“My existence is shit to me — how I feel that I am in eternal suffering, in infinite directions in infinite realities – yet these realities are fake — artificial, induced by thought, how everything connects, yet it’s all so far apart….& I sit and think…”
At first glance, Dylan means to say that his personal suffering was the consequences of his own thinking. People sometimes feel depressed, not because of true events, but because of their own negative perceptions of otherwise neutral or even positive events. Dylan indirectly questions the fabric of reality. The idea that thought induces reality is supported by the science of quantum mechanics: “As observers, we are personally involved with the creation of our own reality,” — in other words, magical thinking. Quantum science explains how matter and energy behave at the smallest levels that scientist can measure. A key concept of quantum science is that scientific observation directly influences the behavior of, for example, electrons and photons. A specific experiment called the Double Slit Experiment proves that certain ‘elements’ can behave as either waves of water or as particles of matter depending on whether a scientific instrument actively observed the individual elements. When the observing device is turned off, the elements behave as waves. When turned on, they behave as particles.
This means that human consciousness, in the form of a scientific observation, probably influences reality at quantum levels. The strangeness of this result left physicists wondering whether there exists a ‘real’ reality that can explain the behavior of quantum elements as either waves or particles. Albert Einstein believed in such a real reality, but his contemporary colleague Niels Bohr disagreed and concluded that reality is not real. “Observations not only disturb what has to be measured, they produce it…We compel [the electron] to assume a definite position… We ourselves produce the results of the measurements.”
Dylan’s comment that “everything connects, yet it’s all so far apart” echoes statements by Greek philosopher Heraclitus: “What was scattered gathers, what was gathered blows apart,” and “From the strain of binding opposites comes harmony.”
Science of the Mind
“Science is the way to find solutions to everything, right? I still think that, yet I see different views of shit now – like the mind – yet if the mind is viewed scientifically…”
Eric Harris made a similar statement on April 21, 1998 that only “science and math are real”. Dylan and Eric accepted the scientific worldview in an otherwise religious America.
Yet if according to quantum science, the mind induces physical reality through the act of conscious observation, then what is the conscious mind, when viewed scientifically? On a biological level, according to philosopher Sam Harris who found support with the science of neurobiology, the conscious mind seats in the secondary brain that wraps around the ‘primitive’ primary brain, or the animal brain. But while we perceive to have free will, this sensation is the result of a cognitive dissonance which means that our primary brain executes commands before the secondary brain becomes aware of them. Our brains fool ourselves into believing that we make conscious decisions, while in reality our animal brain does. The conscious secondary brain merely rationalizes our subconscious choices ex post facto, after the facts.
Even spookier, neurobiologists have proven that, for example, when we ‘decide’ to move our index finger, the primary brain has already fired the electronic signal down our nerve paths before the secondary brain becomes aware of it. Nonetheless, the secondary brain believes to be the initiator of the movement, the source of cognitive dissonance. In this sense, people’s brains fool themselves into believing that they have free will. But what is the mind itself? Where does the sensation of awareness and consciousness come from? The answer has implications in terms of technological progress when we want to build robots that do not just possess artificial intelligence, but also have a conscious mind that can make moral decisions on it’s own account. Over a decade ago, philosophers such as Dan Dennet and scientists such as Jeff Hawkins brought popular attention to the scientific study of the mind.
Past, Present and Future
“A lot on the past though…I’ve always had a thing for the past – how it reacts to the present & the future — or rather vice versa.”
Dylan spent a great deal of his waking life dwelling on the past, on things that depressed him, such as the loss of important friendship or the monotonous school routines he endured at Columbine High.
In several places, he expressed the idea that past, present and future influence each other. One way to interpret this odd belief is from a philosophical point of view. As we grow older, we accumulate experiences and we develop our personality and emotions. We gain new insights and gain a better understanding of our own social realities. As a consequence, the view we have of ourselves changes over time, and we alter our interpretations of the past. As teenagers we may find fault in ourselves when a love interest rejects us, while as adults, we learn that others reject us because they fail to see the good in us, and that rejection therefore is not our fault.
How much we remember of our past selves also changes our perception. The mind is not a device that flawlessly records events, but one that produces sensations blurred by emotion and faulty memory. Who we are today depends on the narrative we tell of our past. Conversely, who we imagine to be in the future influences how we act today, which in tern affects how we see our past selves. For example, if I decide to become a CEO in the future, I may tell myself that I have always been interested in business eve since I was a kid, or that I was born to be a business leader. When we look at a picture of ourselves when we were a baby, we have to tell a story of how we grew up and became the adult we are today, but this story will be largely a fiction based on incomplete memories and wishful polish.
True Human Nature
“They don’t know beyond this world (how I do in my mind or in reality, or in this existence) yet we each are lacking something that the other possesses – I lack the true human nature that Dylan owned, & they lack the overdeveloped mind / imagination / knowledge tool.”
Everything we know about the world around us comes through our biological senses of smell, touch, sight, sound and taste. Even when we use scientific equipment to supposedly observe reality without interference from human sense, we interpret those scientific results with our sense nonetheless. It therefore makes sense that Dylan jumbled together the concepts of mind, reality and existence. Everything we call reality exists only as an observation of the mind that processes our senses. The image we have of our reality can therefore never be of any real reality.
In this statement, Dylan tells us how far he feels removed from ‘normal’ people, because of his ‘overdeveloped’ mind. He means to say that normal people have a seemingly natural access to ‘true’ human nature, namely love, friendship and relationships. But they lack the ability for deeper interpretations of the world around them. Dylan would rather have been less intelligent and more intuitive. He considers himself a sufferer of complicated intelligence and hyper awareness.
When he writes about “the true human nature that Dylan owned” he refers to an earlier remark “when Dylan Benet Klebold got covered up by this entity containing Dylan’s body”. It seemed that Dylan feels that he went through a transformation, from an ordinary human being into a person with an overactive mind. At the same time, his newfound intellect, this ability to incessantly question the reality of the world around him, became a burden.
What does it mean when your intellect gets in the way of acting human? If ignorance is bliss, what should the intellectual do?
Eternal Peace
“The thinking of suicide gives me hope, that I’ll be in my place wherever I go after this life… that I’ll finally not be at war with myself, the world, the universe–my mind, body, everywhere, everything at PEACE in me – my soul (existence).”
Life is war. Dylan expressed his teenage inability to cope with life’s challenges. Here he offered a hint of what he really means with the word existence: “(…) me, my soul (existence),”namely his own being, how he exists in the world among his peers. Of course, in this context the word soul is as obscure as Dylan’s use of the word existence.
This gem of a book can be purchased on Amazon and you will be able to read the rest which includes Eric’s philosophy. I highly recommend it!
Part 1